A few days ago, I had one of those conversations I absolutely love having with colleagues.
She's a nutritionist, and I love these talks because they make me curious. They challenge what I think I know and, most importantly, they give me a chance to expand the way I think.
We needed to swap an ingredient in a recipe.
My first question was: why?
Not out of ego. Quite the opposite. It came from a genuine wish to understand.
The ingredient was allulose, which we'd used in place of sugar. The recipe already had dates, but I wanted to improve the flavor a little, so she suggested either honey or regular sugar.
And I immediately said:
No honey. Honey is toxic when heated.
We talked it through. But I left the conversation thinking about my own answer.
I had stated something very firmly, when what I really should have done was explain where that belief comes from.
A lot of what I say and believe comes from my studies, my experience, and the things I've read, explored, and learned along the way. And I know that nutrition keeps evolving.
We learn more. We question old beliefs. Sometimes the information changes. And sometimes we discover that something we thought was a fact is really a traditional belief, an interpretation, or simply more complicated than we thought.
So I went back to the question:
Is heated honey actually toxic?
The short answer: there's no good evidence that cooking honey turns it into a toxin that harms us.
Heating does change honey's composition. One thing that can increase is HMF (5-hydroxymethylfurfural), a compound that forms when sugars are exposed to heat. It's one reason heating matters when we talk about honey's quality.
But that's very different from saying "heated honey is toxic."
There's another perspective I find fascinating: Ayurveda.
In Ayurveda, honey has traditionally been considered something that shouldn't be heated.
Here's the part I had misunderstood myself: ama is often translated as "toxin," but it's better understood as something the body hasn't properly digested, transformed, or assimilated.
So the Ayurvedic idea isn't simply "raw honey is good, heated honey is poison." It's closer to this:
- Properly transformed → easier to assimilate
- Improperly transformed → harder to digest → potentially ama-forming
That's a very different statement, and I like the distinction.
Maybe the lesson isn't that we need to label foods as good or bad, toxic or healthy. Maybe we need to get a little more comfortable saying:
This is what I currently understand.
And then asking: but why?
That question is one of my favorite places to start. Nutrition isn't supposed to make us stop being curious. It should make us more curious.
And yes… I might still choose not to bake with honey. But now I know how to explain why — and I know "toxic" wasn't the right word.
And that's okay. We're all learning. 🤍
